Gotham Pizza

1667 1st Ave, New York, NY 10028 Order now
Hero image

The BEST Pizza in NYC, as revealed by many.


Our reviews

Reviews from Grubhub

Gotham Pizza Reviews on Grubhub


Top Reviewer
The best pizza Ive ever had in nyc. They forgot to bring my soda that I paid for though.


2 reviews
First time ordering from there, will order again. Good food and good prices


Top Reviewer
Good pizza, glad they are delivering in our area again


2 reviews
Always on time, always good pizza


Top Reviewer
Great food! I would recommend

Reviews from

Gotham Pizza Reviews on Seamless


1 review
In a neighborhood with a lot of solid pizza options, this place might be my favorite. Im a crispy crust guy and theres something about the crust at Gotham thats just head and shoulders above any other joint Ive tried in this part of the city. I dont know what they do to the pies over there to get such a satisfying crunch while still baking the dough to perfection with absolutely zero char/burnt bits but whatever it is, somebody deserves an award for it. Its kind of insane. The sauce and toppings are dank too, which I guess is kind of important.

Once and a while the orders arrive a little later than Seamless says they will but honestly, its worth it. Get this pizza, yall.


Top Reviewer
My goto Pizza place. Love their Grandma pie but regular pie is good too. Timely delivery and never got an order wrong yet and I order often.


Top Reviewer
A great neighborhood pizza place. I especially love the white pizza and the Buffalo chicken pizza.


3 reviews
Consistently good pizza. Hot, delicious, and everything you want out of a delivery pie.


1 review
Everything was great. Havent been to it but gotten delivery from. Great quality food

About us

Dinner, Lunch Specials, Pizza
Delivery: 10:30 AM - 11:30 PM
Takeout: 10:30 AM - 11:30 PM

Gotham Pizza is well known on the Upper East Side for offering delicious pizza. Gotham Pizza is open for lunch and dinner so no matter what time youre craving a delicious meal they can satisfy your hunger. Pizza pies and salads are prepared quickly and delivered to you right away. Gotham Pizza uses only the freshest ingredients around, ensuring that every dish is of the highest possible quality. Not sure what youre in the mood for? Try Gotham Pizzas Grandma Pizza, Its The perfect bite to satisfy your hunger any time of day. Order online or stop by Gotham Pizza today!